The RCR18 is classified by Land Pride as a “lightweight” implement, whereas the RCR12 is tagged with their even lighter “economical” classification. This is very misleading.
For example, the “Bush Hog” brand of rotary cutters classifies their 1″ cutter (BH110) as “light duty”. In contrast, Land Pride classifies their 2″ cutter (RCR18) as “light duty”. That’s a big difference in capabilities , but yet the classification of “light-duty” is used for both.
After some research between RCR18 vs RCR12, I chose to go with the 2″ capacity of the 18-series over the 1″ capacity of the 12-series, but they’re both reasonable options.
Below are some considerations that led me to pick the RCR18 over the RCR12.
Land Pride’s classification system from cheapest to most expensive
| Classification | Cutting Capacity |
|---|---|
| economical | 1" |
| light-duty *** | 2" |
| heavy-duty | 3" |
| brute | 4" |
Medium Duty vs. Light Duty Rotary Cutters
Though designations vary across brands, “medium duty” generally indicates a sturdier machine capable of cutting 2″ saplings, whereas “light-duty” means the implement can handle up to 1″ brush.
RCR18 is Medium Duty
In my view, the RCR18, when compared to other brands, is really a medium duty brush hog, as per Land Pride, it has a 2″ cutting capacity.
RCR12 is Light Duty
The RCR12 serves as Land Pride’s “economy” model, which is really more in line with the “light-duty” models of other brands.
The 12 series is recommended for materials up to 1″ thick. With this model, you should stick to smaller growth like blackberry bushes and other small brush.
Light duty is perfectly fine for some folks!
As you can see, there is a huge difference in the cutting capacity between a medium duty and a light duty. With that said, there is truly nothing wrong with a light duty 1″ capable cutter.
If all you’re going to be doing is cutting established fields that you are familiar with, a light duty mower is perfectly fine. If however, you plan to venture into the woods or into unfamiliar fields, a medium duty cutter is worth the extra cash.
RCR18 vs RCR12 Construction Quality
The RCR18 is constructed with a thicker metal deck that can withstand substantial wear and tear, setting it apart from the RCR12. This difference is evident in the total weight of the implement, with the RCR1860 being over 100 pounds heavier than the RCR1260.
Both the 12 and 18 series share common features like an all-welded deck and a 10-gauge stump jumper, adding to their durability.
However, the heavier weight of the RCR18 and other more premium models needs to be taken into consideration. My Kubota L2501 equipped with a front loader manages the RCR1860 just fine, but your tractor’s capability may vary.
A comparison of 3 popular 60″ Land Pride rotary cutters
| RCR1860 | RCR1260 | RCF2060 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gearbox Warranty | 5 years | 3 years | 5 years |
| Cutting Capacity | 2" | 1" | 2" |
| Quick Hitch Compatible | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Floating Top Link | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Stump Jumper | 10 Ga. | 10 Ga. | 10 Ga. with 1" blade holder |
| Recommended HP | 20-65hp | 20-60hp | 20-65hp |
| Deck Thickness | 10 Ga. (thicker) | 12 Ga. (thinner) | 10 Ga. |
| Side Thickness | 10 Ga. | 12 Ga. | 10 Ga. |
| Weight | 599 lbs. | 496 lbs. | 620 lbs. |
| Deck Height | 7.5" | 7.25" | 9 11/16" |
Warranty
The RCR18 has an upgraded gearbox warranty over the RCR12. It offers an extended 5-year warranty over the 3-year warranty found on the RCR12 series.
Can you see the differences in quality?
Below you can easily see the superior deck bracing of the RCR1860 shown in the 1st image in comparison to the lighter bracing found on the RCR1260 in the second image.
Costs
Opting for the RCR18 series comes with a higher price tag, but in my view the upgrade is well worth the investment.
To give you an idea of the price difference, in 2023 my dealer charged $600 more for the RCR1860 over the RCR1260.
Unless your intended use is limited to cutting weeds and light brush in familiar fields, you might find yourself regretting the choice of the RCR12 series.
The Land Pride RCR1860 Is More Durable Than The RCR1260
With its thicker steel construction and stronger components the 18 series will hold up better over time than the 12 series will.
Over the years, the RCR1860 has built a solid reputation, and my own experience with it confirms that positive feedback. Despite subjecting my cutter to some rigorous use, I still find it to be in great condition.
The RCR1860 has been out a pretty good while – at least since 2014. So, this model is a proven performer.
A Few Features Found On Both Models
Floating 3 point connection
The RCR18 and RCR12 series both have a floating 3 point pivot point that allows the cutter to follow along with the contours of the ground.
Not all brands of cutters have a floating top link. Without it, the cutter is more prone to scalp certain dips in the terrain and generally cut more uneven.
Quick Hitch Ready
Both models are Quick Hitch ready.
The Quick Hitch system allows you to quickly swap between implements. You will have to purchase the 3 point Quick Hitch attachment for your tractor in order to take advantage of this feature.
Slip Clutch vs. Shear Pin
Both the 12 and 18 series offer the choice of a slip clutch or a shear pin.
Most tractor owners consider the slip clutch to be superior to the cheaper shear pin style of PTO clutch.
You’ll have to decide for yourself if you prefer the superior protection of a shear pin vs the convenience of a slip clutch.
A slip clutch offers great protection, but it must be occasionally maintained in order to operate properly.
The shear pins have their own type of hassle that you’ll have to deal with. Shear bolts will occasionally break, by design, and you’ll have to stop whatever you’re doing to address it. That can be a bit of a hassle when you’re trying to get something done and get to the house.
Get a slip clutch on your rotary cutter! Most people prefer it over the cheaper shear bolt design.
Conclusion
While you can certainly spend more money to purchase better rotary cutters, Land Pride’s economy and lightweight models are pretty good for what they are. I had to pay nearly $2400 for an RCR1860, which was about as much as I wanted to spend.
Land Pride’s low end models are certainly better than lesser quality brands that you can pick up at places like Tractor Supply.
If you want to buy new and are on a budget, I think the RCR18 series is well worth a look. However, I think the RCR12 series is a bit too light, unless your intention is to only use it in familiar and established fields.
Good luck with your purchase!
Augustus Clay
